
GREENWOOD, S.C.; November 19, 2026 – A man will spend the next 30 years in prison after a jury found him guilty Wednesday of shooting and killing his mentally ill adult stepson, 8th Circuit Solicitor David M. Stumbo announced Thursday.
A jury deliberated about two hours following an eight-day trial and returned a verdict of guilty on a charge of murder for William Bryan Morgan, 36, who prosecutors said took the law into his own hands and killed his mentally ill stepson, 29-year-old Caleb Donnelly.
Circuit Judge Thomas William McGee III then sentenced Morgan to 30 years in prison, which must be served day for day with no possibility of parole under South Carolina law.
In June 2021, deputies were called to a domestic dispute between Morgan and Donnelly that occurred at a party at another residence. Deputies eventually took Donnelly to his residence, a small outbuilding behind Morgan’s residence that Donnelly had converted into his “room,” to separate the parties in an attempt to de-escalate the situation. A short time later, deputies were called to Morgan’s residence after Donnelly damaged property inside Morgan’s home.
While deputies were on scene speaking with Donnelly’s mother, Morgan returned to the residence, retrieved a .357 Magnum revolver, and went looking for Donnelly. Deputies informed Donnelly’s mother that they had enough to obtain a warrant for Donnelly’s arrest for damaging Morgan’s property. The warrant would presumably keep Donnelly in jail for the weekend so Donnelly’s family could seek help for his mental illness. Not long after deputies left from Morgan’s residence, they were called a third time when Donnelly’s body was discovered in his small outbuilding.
Morgan fled the scene and was located two days later coming out of the woods not far from his home. During an interview, Morgan admitted to killing Donnelly by shooting his stepson several times. Morgan admitted he took matters into his own hands and told investigators he fired the last shot into Donnelly’s neck to put Donnelly “out of his misery.”
Deputy Solicitor Yates Brown and Assistant Solicitor Madison Hoffman handled the case for the state with assistance from 8th Circuit Investigator Dyar Archibald and 8th Circuit Victim Advocate Rhetta Smith. Morgan was represented by attorneys Rose Mary Parham, Shipp Daniel and Ray Chandler of the Pee Dee area.
Solicitor Stumbo praised the work of his staff, along with Capt. Matthew Womack of the Greenwood County Sheriff’s Office, in securing the conviction and lengthy prison sentence.
“William Morgan hunted down and killed a family member simply because he had grown weary of dealing with the symptoms of Caleb’s mental illness,” Solicitor Stumbo said following the sentencing. “Caleb deserved compassion, not bloodshed and death, from family that he trusted. Our office will continue to stand up for vulnerable victims and hold those who harm them accountable.”